Zoom with a view
Think remote work is dead? Nope. It just moved to the office
A FAMILIAR REFRAIN from anyone forced back into the office over the past year goes something like this: “I can’t believe I’m forced to go back into the office, only to sit on Teams calls all day.”
Click here to view this article in the London Inc. Worklife newsletter
Maybe you passed it off as mere grouchiness from someone who really doesn’t want to be at the office, but a new study from the New York Federal Reserve and researchers Natalia Emanuel (of the NY Fed) and Emma Harrington (of the University of Virginia) found that the complainers aren’t wrong: RTO mandates haven’t ended remote work, remote work has now just moved into the office.
“Roughly half of in-office days are spent entirely on Zoom calls or doing solo work,” the report, released in October, found. “These workers commute in just to work remotely from the office. Existing measures of remote work that focus solely on working from home miss up to three quarters of its true prevalence.”
“The office has become less effective in delivering on its promise of co-location with colleagues. Many workers’ commutes are simply yielding a new background for their Zoom calls”
There is a form of received wisdom out there in the world of work that these RTO mandates are all about boosting in-person collaboration, or are borne out of a frustration with the tools and infrastructure of remote work creating inefficiencies. This report is agnostic on the arguments for or against RTO mandates, but suggests that the mandates often aren’t delivering the in-person contact they promise.
“The office has become less effective in delivering on its promise of co-location with colleagues,” the authors wrote. “Many workers’ commutes are simply yielding a new background for their Zoom calls.”
The report, which is based on a survey of around 1,800 workers, plus badge-swipe data from one unnamed Fortune 500 company, paints a picture of in-office days that “often lack human contact” and are spent “online, as they would if working remotely.”
No one will be reading this report with more enthusiasm and more “See, I told you so!” than Canadian public employees, who have complained loudly over the past couple of years about constant RTO mandates, only to see a workplace that is in most respects a remote one.
Story Continues Below
Saying that federal offices have “a call-centre vibe,” Rebecca Anne Clark told HR Reporter that offices are now crowded and noisy, with staff seated close together while attending separate virtual meetings. One public servant told CTV that “I’m coming into the office to do basically what I would do at home.”
None of this means the authors think the mandates are pointless. Their point is narrower, though: showing up isn’t the same as being with anyone.
“Many return to office mandates encourage presence in the office,” the authors said. “But many offices fail to deliver proximity to teammates, underscoring the difference between presence and proximity.”
Kieran Delamont
